Sharebuilder Review

by Jon Dulin

sharebuilder reviewFor those of my readers that don’t know, I use Capital One 360 as my primary bank. I have both a checking and savings account through them. Every so often, I get an email from them regarding their investing arm through Sharebuilder. I never have been interested in Sharebuilder as I use Schwab for my investing. I have had no issues with Schwab and the fees that I pay to trade stocks are reasonable.

Most of the offers from Sharebuilder are for free trades, which I am not really interested in because I do not do a lot of trading. I mainly invest in mutual funds and ETF’s and hold for the long term. However, the recent offer I received for $50 interested me. I decided to look at the site.

Sharebuilder Review

While I feel that Sharebuilder is not ideal for stock purchases, it could be a nice starting point for small mutual fund investors. Through Sharebuilder you can invest in over 250 mutual funds from 8 fund families including American Century, PIMCO, Fidelity, T Rowe Price, and Vanguard. Unfortunately, if you invest in Vanguard, T Rowe Price, Fidelity, or Dodge & Cox, you will pay $19.95 per trade. If you want to set up an automatic investing plan, that will cost you $4 per investment.

I refuse to pay to invest in these fund families. Luckily though, there are some good funds offered through the other four fund families that do not charge a fee for you to invest in. They include American Century, PIMCO, ING Funds, and Dreyfus. Even better, if you invest in American Century directly, the fund minimums are $2,500. But, if you invest through Sharebuilder, the minimum is $250. This is great for small investors who don’t have $2,500 to start. From there, you will need $100 to invest each time again.

Sharebuilder Review: Stock Investing

The reason I am against Sharebuilder for stock investing is if you are a small investor, you should be focusing on investing in mutual funds so that you are diversified. Investing in one stock is not diversified. For normal stock trades, you will pay $6.95 per trade. If you sign up for the basic automatic investing plan, the fee is reduced to $4 per trade. If you upgrade to the advantage automatic investing plan, the fee is $12 per month which includes the first 12 trades. Any additional trades are $1 each.

If you are going to invest in a stock frequently, you have two options. The first is to save up the money you want to invest in the stock and make a one-time purchase for the $6.95 fee. It makes no sense to buy 1 share of stock each month for $4, or pay $12 per month for the privilege if you aren’t going to trade that frequently.

The second option is to accumulate investing credits. Each credit is worth one free automatic investing trade. I received on trade on my birthday and was awarded three more when I signed up. A quick online search yielded a handful of promo codes to try. Most weren’t accepted, but some were. In the end, I had eight trade credits. I set up an automatic investing plan in a stock I wanted. I bought once per month for eight months. I never paid a fee as the free trade credits were used each time.

Sharebuilder Review: Mutual Funds

I ended up buying a no-fee mutual fund through Sharebuilder for free. After I made my investment, I was credited with my $50. The account registration process was a breeze (I’m not sure if that was because I already had a Capital One 350 account or not). The transfers of money from Capital One to Sharebuilder are instantaneous, which is awesome. For how I am using Sharebuilder, I think it is a great service. You can find some good, no-load, no-fee mutual funds to invest in with a very low initial investment.

Sharebuilder Review: Other Features

There are three extra features that Sharebuilder offers that I need to mention:

Retire MyWay: This feature helps you to define a plan for the way you want to live in retirement. This is great since you need to have a plan in order to be a successful investor.

Heat Map: The Heat Map feature is a quick look to see how securities are performing by index, sector and more. It’s a great way to get caught up on the market at glance.

Portfolio Analysis: The Portfolio Analysis highlights the asset types and sectors represented in your portfolio.

Sharebuilder Review: Site Navigation

Using the website is easy. Everything was in a logical place. I didn’t have to search around for much. The only thing I did need to search for was how many free trades I had. Once I realized they were listed in the Automatic Investing tab, I had no other issues with the website.

Sharebuilder Review: Customer Service and the Rest

I contacted customer service on a whim, just to see how responsive they are. I actually contacted them a few times via email and each time, they responded within one business day. I thought this was acceptable.

When it comes to taxes, I received an email that my 1099 was ready and was available online. I logged into my account and there it was in the Tax Center.

Overall, the only issue I have with Sharebuilder is that they charge you a fee to close out your account. It is $75 for a full account closure and $40 for a partial closure.

Sharebuilder Review: Conclusion

My Sharebuilder review is complete. Here are the takeaways in bullet points:

  • If you are looking at investing in certain mutual fund families, like Vanguard, you are better off saving up the $3,000 and investing directly with Vanguard as opposed to paying the $19.95 to Sharebuilder.
  • Sharebuilder is great for no-load, no-fee mutual fund investing. They don’t have the relationships that Schwab has with mutual fund families, but they offer a good variety. Sharebuilder knows this, and this is why they offer sign up bonuses to get your business. If you see a fund family you want to invest in and Sharebuilder is offering a sign up bonus, I say go for it.
  • For stocks, if you are making large, sporadic investments, the $6.95 per trade fee is in-line with the industry.
  • If you are going to be trading stocks frequently, I suggest you sign up for the advantage investing plan for $12. If you trade more than two times per month, you’ve already saved money on the trading fee.


Like This Article? Get Future Ones Emailed To You
Enter your email address below and I'll send you new articles right to your inbox. You'll only get an email from me when a new article is written. Spam free...Guaranteed!

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Mildred January 3, 2012 at 3:43 pm

Why does Sharebuilder charge such high fees for Vanguard Funds?


moneysma January 3, 2012 at 3:47 pm


To clarify, most of the mutual fund options on Sharebuilder do not charge a fee. The one's that do (Vanguard, Fidelity, etc) do so because the fund company itself forces sites such as Sharebuilder to pay a fee to offer their funds. It's not just with Sharebuilder. If you try to invest in Vanguard funds through Schwab, then you are looking at a $19.95 per trade fee as well.

As for stocks, the $9.95 is reasonable when compared to many others. Where it really becomes expensive is when you make small re-occurring purchases every month for $4. You are much better off saving your money and investing less frequently.


EL @Moneywatch101 April 2, 2014 at 10:15 am

I have sharebuilder, I think its ok. I don’t like the fact that the 4 dollar trade, you have to schedule it for a specific Tuesday of the month. Besides that it is very user friendly.


Jon Dulin April 3, 2014 at 7:35 am

I agree. I used my free automatic investing credits to buy a bunch of stock without commission and now just buy no transaction fee mutual funds so there is never a charge.


Dividend Diplomats August 9, 2014 at 6:18 pm

Money Smart,

I love sharebuilder. Low fees, automatic free dividend reinvestment plans, plenty of “hoo-has” with free trade credits on the birthday, etc. Also – their research articles are great, seamless transactions between my checking/savings account with them, their express funding is awesome as well – where it’ll pull from the capitalone360 account when you go to trade, so you don’t have to have the cash in there to make the trade. I highly recommend and have been using it for 5 years.

-Lanny, one of the diplomats
Dividend Diplomats recently posted..American Express (AXP) Stock AnalysisMy Profile


Jon Dulin August 11, 2014 at 3:00 pm

The moving of money between the Capital One 360 account and Sharebuilder is a nice feature. It just auto pulls whenever I make a extra step for me involved!


Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: